Dearest Flabby (yeah, right) Abbey,
My very expensive personal trainer has put me on a wacky diet plan that consists of eating in combination (always a starch with a protein) and severely limiting starches, all while consuming 1200 to 1400 calories a day. There is no calorie counting involved, just measuring of portions. My question is, can't I just count calories, eat nutritionally dense, minimally processed foods and get on with my life?! Is sticking to a low calorie diet enough for me to lose weight, or must I be fanatical about what I eat?
Signed,
Sick to damn death of boiled eggs, string cheese and cucumbers
Oh My Lovely Cheesy Egg Head,
First of all, you make me want an omelet. Second of all, send me the check instead of to your personal trainer. Third of all, do not try to use chopsticks after drinking a bottle of wine; you will stain your clothes. Fourth of all (that doesn't sound right), let me answer your question with a question: would you drink a fifth of vodka to refuel after having run a half marathon? No, don't, it's not good. Your body is thriving for a liquid packed with electrolytes to replenish itself. You don't just grab the vodka because it's wet. That would almost kill you...you'd be a human raisin! Okay, connection time:
I'll try to be brief with my response: the 1200-1400 calorie count is the standard BMR for women (Basal Metabolic Rate) which means that if you did nothing but stayed in bed all day, your body would burn 1200 calories for just existing, sounds pretty good to me. So, of course that's the easiest and safest number for your personal trainer to rely on because they are keeping you on a diet that could sustain you if you were bedridden. In turn, this can hurt you because you are not fueling the body for whatever activity you're doing, i.e. walking, running, gossiping, murdering, etc. Therefore, your body goes all Pacman and starts eating your muscle while throwing your calories to the side to store as fat in order to fuel future activities; it's scared it won't get enough later.
Girl, it gets crazy and complicated, and if you want an accurate calorie count, I suggest you look at the Harris Benedict Formula. It's a crazy mathematical equation that lets you know exactly how many calories you should have in day....but seriously, I'm just telling you that so you can see how above and beyond this crap gets...ahhhhhh!!!!!! (nonsense)
Calories used to be the best measure of fuel for your body, but recent studies have proven otherwise. Eating 1200 calories of Tapioca filled Doughnut Sticks (can you tell what my new fave is?) is not the same as eating 1200 calories of fruits, veggies, dairy, and protein. Again, that's like trying to compare vodka to water...they're both wet and clear, but they cannot serve the same purpose. So out with the calories, and in with the protein, fiber, and low fat. If it has 800 calories, but 20 grams of protein and 9 grams of fiber, the calories don't begin to matter! Protein and fiber break down the slowest and do your body the most good, so eat up, sister. Truth be told by your trainer, though, the reason your starches are minimal is because they don't usually contain protein or fiber, and we just discussed that items without those don't really serve a function, but it doesn't mean that they have to be off limits. In fact, nothing should ever be off limits. Again, if you want it, eat it, just don't eat every item of it in a ten mile radius...instant belly ache!
Finally, in answer to your question, yes, ditch the "diet" because if it's called a "diet" then it's not going to work because "diets" are temporary. And no, do not count calories because they don't matter. We're adults, and we've learned over the years that as long as we're active, we eat within proper portions, and we don't go crazy on the fried and processed, our bodies will thrive. You know what good decisions are, and you know what bad decisions are, and the only reason you have a personal trainer is because you want someone outside of you to hold yourself accountable to a plan because without that person, you're more likely to scribble outside of the lines...and that's okay. (Do you really plan to pay for a personal trainer forever...?????)
Always, always, always, always strive to be healthier, let that be your number one goal.
I don't know if this helped, and if you want further explanation on what I'm talking about, you know where to find me. I care about your happiness; I care about your mentality; be you, which is absolutely beautiful...! Now, about that check....
Flabby Abbey
I'll try to be brief with my response: the 1200-1400 calorie count is the standard BMR for women (Basal Metabolic Rate) which means that if you did nothing but stayed in bed all day, your body would burn 1200 calories for just existing, sounds pretty good to me. So, of course that's the easiest and safest number for your personal trainer to rely on because they are keeping you on a diet that could sustain you if you were bedridden. In turn, this can hurt you because you are not fueling the body for whatever activity you're doing, i.e. walking, running, gossiping, murdering, etc. Therefore, your body goes all Pacman and starts eating your muscle while throwing your calories to the side to store as fat in order to fuel future activities; it's scared it won't get enough later.
Girl, it gets crazy and complicated, and if you want an accurate calorie count, I suggest you look at the Harris Benedict Formula. It's a crazy mathematical equation that lets you know exactly how many calories you should have in day....but seriously, I'm just telling you that so you can see how above and beyond this crap gets...ahhhhhh!!!!!! (nonsense)
Calories used to be the best measure of fuel for your body, but recent studies have proven otherwise. Eating 1200 calories of Tapioca filled Doughnut Sticks (can you tell what my new fave is?) is not the same as eating 1200 calories of fruits, veggies, dairy, and protein. Again, that's like trying to compare vodka to water...they're both wet and clear, but they cannot serve the same purpose. So out with the calories, and in with the protein, fiber, and low fat. If it has 800 calories, but 20 grams of protein and 9 grams of fiber, the calories don't begin to matter! Protein and fiber break down the slowest and do your body the most good, so eat up, sister. Truth be told by your trainer, though, the reason your starches are minimal is because they don't usually contain protein or fiber, and we just discussed that items without those don't really serve a function, but it doesn't mean that they have to be off limits. In fact, nothing should ever be off limits. Again, if you want it, eat it, just don't eat every item of it in a ten mile radius...instant belly ache!
Finally, in answer to your question, yes, ditch the "diet" because if it's called a "diet" then it's not going to work because "diets" are temporary. And no, do not count calories because they don't matter. We're adults, and we've learned over the years that as long as we're active, we eat within proper portions, and we don't go crazy on the fried and processed, our bodies will thrive. You know what good decisions are, and you know what bad decisions are, and the only reason you have a personal trainer is because you want someone outside of you to hold yourself accountable to a plan because without that person, you're more likely to scribble outside of the lines...and that's okay. (Do you really plan to pay for a personal trainer forever...?????)
Always, always, always, always strive to be healthier, let that be your number one goal.
I don't know if this helped, and if you want further explanation on what I'm talking about, you know where to find me. I care about your happiness; I care about your mentality; be you, which is absolutely beautiful...! Now, about that check....
Flabby Abbey